Pizza Haven Menu with Prices 2024 [ September Updated ]

Last Updated on May 20, 2024 by Team Mystery Flavours

Craving a slice of history along with your pizza? Look no further than Pizza Haven, a beloved institution satisfying New Yorkers’ appetites for over 80 years. From classic cheese pies to innovative flavor combinations, Pizza Haven has been a staple in the city’s culinary landscape since its founding in 1958. Dive into our comprehensive guide to the Pizza Haven menu, featuring a tantalizing array of options at reasonable prices that have stood the test of time.

Pizza Haven Menu With Prices

Salads Menu

Garden Salad	$10.00
Caesar Salad	$11.00
Greek Salad	$10.00
Choice of Dressings:	$1.00 – Italian, Creamy Italian, Ceasar, Oil & Vinegar $2.00 – Ranch, Blue Cheese, French or Russian

Soup Menu

Minestrone Soup	$7.50
Soup of the Day	$7.50

Side Dishes Menu

Meatballs or Sausage	$13.00 $16.00 – With Cheese
Garlic Knots (4)	$4.00 $6.00 – With Melted Mozzarella Cheese
Garlic Bread	$5.00 $7.00 – With Melted Mozzarella Cheese
French Fries	$6.00
Onion Rings	$7.00
Hot Dog	$4.50
Mozzarella Sticks (6)	$9.00
Zucchini Sticks	$9.00
Chicken Fingers (5)	$10.50 $12.00 – With Fries
Buffalo Wings	$16.00 – 6 $20.00 – 12 $29.00 – 25

Desserts Menu

S&S Cheesecake	$8.00
Cannoli	$7.00
Tiramisu	$8.00

Beverages Menu

Snapple®	$3.50 – 20 oz.
Gatorade®	$3.50 – 20 oz.
Bottled Soda	$3.50 – 20 oz.
Canned Soda Coke®, Diet Coke® or Sprite®	$2.50
2 Liter Soda	$6.75
Bottled Water	$2.50

Pizza Menu

Pizza Type	Mini 12″	Sm 14″	Med 16″	Lrg 18″
Plain Pizza	$15.00	$18.00	$21.00	$23.00
Focaccia			$30.00
Margherita Pizza	$18.00	$20.00	$23.00	$26.00
Hawaiian Pizza	$20.00	$22.00	$23.00	$26.00
Salad Pizza	$20.00	$22.00	$25.00	$28.00
White Pizza	$18.00	$20.00	$23.00	$26.00
Meat Lover’s	$24.00	$28.00	$32.00	$35.00
Veggie Lover’s	$21.00	$24.00	$28.00	$32.00
Haven Special	$25.00	$29.00	$33.00	$36.00
Sicilian Pizza			$30.00
Sicilian Special			$45.00
Lasagna Pizza	$24.00	$28.00	$32.00	$35.00
Buffalo Chicken Pizza	$21.00	$25.00	$29.00	$33.00

Pizza Toppings Menu

Topping Type	Mini	Sm	Med	Lrg
Regular Toppings Ea.	$5.50	$6.00	$7.00	$7.50
Regular Toppings Half Pie	$5.00	$5.25	$6.00	$6.50
Special Toppings Ea.	$7.00	$7.50	$8.50	$9.00
Special Toppings Half Pie	$5.75	$6.00	$6.75	$7.00

Calzones, Stromboli & Hippie Rolls Menu

Cheese Calzone	$9.75
Add any 1 Topping (regular)	$2.00
Add any 1 Topping (special)	$2.50
Stromboli	$10.00
Hippie Rolls	$10.00
Chicken Roll	$10.00
Pepperoni Roll	$7.50
Pig In A Blanket	$5.00
Extra Cheese	$2.00

Hot Heros Menu

Meatball	$15.00
Meatball Parmigiana	$16.00
Sausage	$15.00
Sausage Parmigiana	$16.00
Sausage & Peppers	$17.00
Sausage & Peppers Parmigiana	$18.00
Chicken Cutlet	$15.50
Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana	$16.50
Eggplant	$15.00
Eggplant Parmigiana	$16.00
Veal Cutlet	$16.00
Veal Cutlet Parmigiana	$17.00
Shrimp	$16.00
Shrimp Parmigiana	$17.00

Wraps Menu

Buffalo Chicken Wrap	$11.50
Chicken Caesar Wrap	$11.50

Patties Menu

Beef Pattie	$4.25
Beef Pattie with Cheese	$6.25
Beef Pattie with Pepperoni	$6.25
Beef Pattie with Pepperoni & Cheese	$8.25
Beef Pattie with Coco Bread	$6.50
Beef Pattie with Pepperoni & Coco Bread	$8.50
Beef Pattie with Pepperoni & Cheese & Coco Bread	$10.50

Greek Specialties Menu

Spanakopita	$9.00
Tiropita	$8.50
Gyro	$11.50
Gyro Platter	$15.50

Pastas Menu

Spaghetti or Penne	$12.50
with Handmade Meatballs	$16.50
with Sweet Italian Sausage	$16.50
with Fresh Broccoli	$15.50
with Homemade Meat Sauce	$16.50
Stuffed Shells	$15.50
Meat or Cheese Ravioli	$15.50
Manicotti	$15.50

Baked Pastas Menu

Baked Penne	$17.00
with Breaded Chicken Cutlet	$20.00
with Homemade Meatballs	$20.00
with Breaded Eggplant	$20.00
with Italian Sausage	$20.00
with Veal	$22.00
with Shrimp	$22.00
Lasagna	$21.00

Dinners Menu

Veal Cutlet Parmigiana	23.00
Shrimp Parmigiana	23.00
Sausage Parmigiana	20.50
Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana	20.50
Eggplant Parmigiana	20.50
Sausage & Peppers	20.50

Despite the twists and turns of its journey, Pizza Haven remains a beacon of quality and tradition in the bustling streets of New York City. Whether you’re a longtime fan or a newcomer eager to experience a slice of history, Pizza Haven’s menu continues to offer something for everyone, ensuring that the legacy of this iconic pizzeria lives on for generations to come. Indulge in the flavors of the past and present with Pizza Haven – where every bite is a taste of nostalgia.