Last Updated on May 22, 2024 by Team Mystery Flavours
In an era dominated by large franchise operations, Pizza My Heart has maintained a strong presence with its roots deeply embedded in the Californian soil. Starting from a humble setup in Capitola, it has grown to encompass 11 locations that serve a broad array of customers across the region. What sets Pizza My Heart apart is not just its pizzas but the connection it seeks to establish with local culture and its clientele, blending food with a sense of community.
The diversity of their menu, highlighted by award-winning pizzas such as the Big Sur and Figgy Piggy, caters to a wide range of tastes from the traditional to the more adventurous. Moreover, the pricing structure is transparent, and though it might be considered premium, it reflects the quality and size options offered—from 12-inch pizzas for those wanting something small, up to 18-inch pies for family gatherings.
Their menu’s versatility extends beyond pizzas. With options for vegans and vegetarians like The Mendocino and The Classic, along with the ability to customize your pizza from the crust up, ensures that there’s something for everyone. The inclusion of salads, wings, and unique desserts like the KOOK-IE and Cinna-Bomb broadens their appeal.
The operational model of Pizza My Heart, with extended hours and delivery options, aligns well with modern lifestyle demands, providing convenience without compromising on the dining experience. Their historical journey from a single small outlet to a significant local chain speaks volumes about their commitment to quality and customer service.
Pizza My Heart Menu With Prices
Award Winning Pizzas
| Big Sur | 12″ – $20.75 14″ – $28.75 18″ – $37.50 |
| Little Sur | 12″ – $20.75 14″ – $28.75 18″ – $37.50 |
| Figgy Piggy | 12″ – $20.75 14″ – $28.75 18” – $37.50 |
| Virgin Creek | 12″ – $20.75 14″ – $28.75 18″ – $37.50 |
| Watsonville Apple | 12″ – $20.75 14″ – $28.75 18″ – $37.50 |
| Fort Point | 12″ – $20.75 14″ – $28.75 18″ – $37.50 |
Specialty Pizzas with Meat
| Big Sur | 12″ – $20.75 14″ – $28.75 18″ – $37.50 |
| D’Lex Chicken & Bacon | 12” – $20.75 14” – $28.75 18” – $37.50 |
| Maui Wowie | 12” – $18.75 14” – $24.75 18” – $31.50 |
| Watsonville Apple | 12″ – $20.75 14″ – $28.75 18″ – $37.50 |
| Cowell’s Combo | 12” – $20.75 14” – $28.75 18” – $37.50 |
| Doheny Sweet Heat | 12″ – $20.75 14″ – $28.75 18″ – $37.50 |
| Maverick’s | 12″ – $20.75 14″ – $28.75 18″ – $37.50 |
| Rockaway | 12” – $20.75 14” – $28.75 18” – $37.50 |
| Sunset Beach | 12” – $20.75 14” – $28.75 18” – $37.50 |
| Figgy Piggy | 12″ – $20.75 14″ – $28.75 18″ – $37.50 |
| Davenport | 12” – $20.75 14” – $28.75 18” – $37.50 |
| Fort Point | 12″ – $20.75 14″ – $28.75 18″ – $37.50 |
| The Lane | 12” – $19.75 14” – $26.75 18” – $34.50 |
| Depot Hill | 12” – $20.75 14” – $28.75 18” – $37.50 |
| Wingnut’s | 12″ – $18.75 14″ – $24.75 18″ – $31.50 |
| Pleasure Point | 12” – $20.75 14” – $28.75 18” – $37.50 |
| Todos Santos | 12” – $20.75 14” – $28.75 18” – $37.50 |
Vegan & Vegetarian Specialty Pizzas
| Manresa | 12” – $19.75 14” – $26.75 18” – $34.50 |
| The Hook | 12” – $20.75 14″ – $28.75 18″ – $37.50 |
| Pesto | 12” – $18.75 14” – $24.75 18” – $31.50 |
| Castroville | 12” – $20.75 14” – $28.75 18” – $37.50 |
| The MT. Diablo – Vegan | 12″ – $20.75 14″ – $28.75 18″ – $37.50 |
| Vegan Big Sur | 12″ – $20.75 14″ – $28.75 18″ – $37.50 |
| Little Sur | 12″ – $20.75 14″ – $28.75 18″ – $37.50 |
| Linda Mar | 12” – $20.75 14” – $28.75 18” – $37.50 |
| The Classic | 12” – $18.75 14” – $24.75 18” – $31.50 |
| Sand Dollar | 12” – $19.75 14” – $26.75 18” – $34.50 |
| Prima | 12” – $18.75 14” – $24.75 18” – $31.50 |
| Asilomar | 12” – $20.75 14” – $28.75 18” – $37.50 |
| Natural Bridges | 12” – $19.75 14” – $26.75 18” – $34.50 |
| Virgin Creek | 12″ – $20.75 14″ – $28.75 18″ – $37.50 |
| Santa Cruz | 12” – $19.75 14” – $26.75 18” – $34.50 |
| The Mendocino – Vegan | 12″ – $20.75 14″ – $28.75 18″ – $37.50 |
Design Your Own Pizza
| Cheese Pizza | 12″ – $16.75 14″ – $20.75 18″ – $25.50 |
| Cheese Pizza (1 Topping) | 12″ – $17.75 14″ – $22.75 18″ – $28.50 |
| Cheese Pizza (2 Toppings) | 12″ – $18.75 14″ – $24.75 18″ – $31.50 |
| Cheese Pizza (3 Toppings) | 12″ – $19.75 14″ – $26.75 18″ – $34.50 |
| Cheese Pizza (4 Toppings) | 12″ – $20.75 14″ – $28.75 18″ – $37.50 |
| Heart Shaped Pizza | 14″ – $27.50 |
Snacks & Salads
| Chicken Wings (Six Wings) | $10.99 |
| Chicken Wings (Twelve Wings) | $17.99 |
| Chicken Wings (Twenty-four Wings) | $29.99 |
| Boneless Chicken Wings (Six Wings) | $10.99 |
| Boneless Chicken Wings (Twelve Wings) | $17.99 |
| Boneless Chicken Wings (Twenty-four Wings) | $29.99 |
| Bread Stix | $8.50 |
| Bread Stix with Mozzarella Cheese | $10.50 |
| Classic Caesar | Regular – $7.50 Large – $43.00 |
| Classic Caesar with Chicken | Regular – $8.75 Large – $48.00 |
| Greek Salad | Regular – $6.50 Large – $36.00 |
| Seasonal Greens | Regular – $6.50 Large – $36.00 |
| Chicken Walnut | Regular $8.75 Large – $48.00 |
| KOOK-IE | $7.50 |
| Cinna-Bomb | $7.50 |
Slices
| Old-School Pepperoni | $5.35 |
| The Big Sur | $5.85 |
| D’Lex Chicken & Bacon | $5.85 |
| Maui Wowie | $5.85 |
| Pepperoni & Sausage | $5.85 |
| Cheese | $4.85 |
| Pesto | $5.35 |
| Super Veggie | $5.85 |
| Manresa | $5.85 |
Drinks
| Bottled Drink | 20 oz. – $3.00 |
| Fountain Soda | $2.60 |
| Milk | $2.60 |
| Apple Juice | $2.60 |
| Water | $2.60 |
| Mexican Soft Drinks (Coke, Sprite) | $3.00 |
Despite the growth, Pizza My Heart maintains a local charm that resonates with both residents and visitors, making it not just a place to eat but a destination to experience. The fact that they continue to thrive in a competitive market is a testament to their consistent quality and innovative approach to casual dining. This model, while specific to their Californian roots, could potentially be a blueprint for similar success in other regions, should they ever decide to expand beyond their current locales.
